Facebook Twitter Instagram
    FeedTheHabit.com
    • Home
    • Gear Reviews
      • Mountain Biking
      • Road Biking
      • Bike Commuting
      • Trail Running
      • Skiing
      • Outdoors
      • Water Sports
      • Vehicles
    • News
    • Trip Reports
    • Videos
    FeedTheHabit.com
    Gear Reviews

    Mountain Hardwear Mesa V2 Convertible Pant Review

    Kevin GloverBy Kevin GloverSeptember 14, 20131 Comment4 Mins Read

    There are a few pieces of gear that we’ve all had for years (or buy consistently year after year) just because they work so darn well. Mountain Hardwear promised that the Mesa convertible pant would provide that kind of experience, and for me that sets a very high level of expectation. I had a blast testing the Mesas during a backpacking trip to the Sangre de Cristo mountains of New Mexico.

    Mountain Hardwear Mesa V2 Convertible Pants Features:

    • Mesh drain panels in pockets
    • Zippered side pocket, with key clip
    • Convert to shorts with an 11″ inseam
    • Full-length inseam gusset for mobility
    • DWR finish repels water
    • Apparel Fit: Relaxed
    • Weight 10.6 oz. / 299 g
    • Inseam Length 30,32,34″ / 76 cm
    • MSRP: $75

    S13_OM5253_015_f

    My Experience

    The Mesas are a pretty straightforward pant as far as convertibles are concerned: a light, quick-drying fabric, five pockets and a DWR to keep rain showers out. The pants fit slightly tight through the thigh (or, at least, they will if you’re a cyclist) and tend toward athletic fitting. The right leg has a zippered pocket for security, though the zip is tough to open with one hand.

    The athletic fit becomes something of a problem when you’re trying to drag a compass or multitool out of your pocket – I definitely encountered a little of what I call “fat-woman-in-jeans-trying-to-reach-cell-phone” syndrome with these pants. It’s not a big deal, and I’m perfectly content to shift easy-access items to the butt pockets or zippered cargo pocket.

    Zippered side pocket with security hook
    Zippered side pocket with security hook

    For performance, I had mixed feelings about the pants. They move well in technical scrambles and I never felt encumbered by the pant – that full-length gusset is a must-have. However, I had a few issues with some of the other aspects of the product. For one thing, the DWR held up well until its first brisk scrub in a mountain stream, and then disappeared entirely (even when I got home and chucked them in the dryer to buck up the DWR). Moreover, the product fabric and stitching ran into failures as well – I ripped out the crotch with around 50 miles on the pant and there’s some failure of both fabric and stitching on the pants.

    The ripped crotch is doubtless a result of the tight cut around the thigh, but I’m hardly out of the way as far as size is concerned: I’m 5′ 11″ and weigh 193 and, while I am a cyclist, there are definitely bigger quads out there. Overall, I’d call it an old-fashioned product failure, either due to poor design, poor manufacturing standards or poor quality control. Perhaps all three. The worn fabric and torn stitching, though, is completely unacceptable – these pants have around 70 miles on them, which is just a fraction of the miles that an avid backpacker can put on in a summer. Admittedly, $70 does not buy into the upper echelon of hiking lowers, but it’s in a price range where I would expect better performance.

    One of several failures that these shorts experienced
    One of several failures that these shorts experienced

    Beyond these rather serious failures, I really like the pant design – they zip off easily, dry quickly and move well. I personally like their quad-hugging feel and I’m not too put off that I need to stitch up the crotch. Hardwear’s waistband feels good under a pack and the UPF 50 rating (an absolute must-have for me) keeps my legs pasty white. I just wish they held up better!

    The Good:

    • Great fabric: light, cool and quick-drying
    • Security pocket is convenient, reasonably sized
    • Titanium color (tested) wears well in the backcountry – stains are a no-show

    The Bad:

    • Poor DWR longevity after washing
    • Fabric failures in crotch and hem
    • Security pocket zip doesn’t pull easily enough

    The Bottom Line

    Mountain Hardwear promised me that these pants would quickly become an old favorite; while I did indeed love the fit and function of the pants, they simply don’t hold up well enough. Mountain Hardwear may do well to reconsider how tight they’re tailoring the thighs, since a lot of outdoorsmen are, well, muscular. Go figure. I really want to recommend these pants since I loved them before the failures started showing up, but in their current iteration I think I would give these pants a pass unless you want to buy three pairs in a season.

    Buy now: Available from Moosejaw.com

    ShareTweet
    mountain hardwear pants
    Previous Article2013 Felt Edict Nine 3 Long-term Review
    Next Article Sherpa Adventure Gear Kanchan Tee Review
    Kevin Glover
    • Website

    Kevin Glover lives, climbs and backpacks out of Spokane, WA. Originally from the Nevada high desert, he moved to the PNW ten years ago and has worked as a glacier and rock guide in the Washington Cascades. When not testing gear, he is a medical student at the University of Washington and will gladly check that rash out for you.

    You Might Also Like

    Black Diamond StormLine Stretch Rain Shell Review

    March 29, 2023

    Pearl Izumi PRO Barrier Jacket Review

    March 27, 2023

    Velocio Concept Merino Long Sleeve Jersey Review

    March 22, 2023

    1 Comment

    1. Phil on September 14, 2013 11:33 pm

      Well noted. I will take that into account. Thanks for the advice.

      Reply

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Most Popular

    Wahoo ELEMNT Rival Multisport GPS Watch Review

    March 9, 2022
    8.9

    Zipp 303 S Carbon Wheelset Review

    November 4, 2021
    9.2

    SRAM Rival XPLR eTap AXS Groupset Review

    August 12, 2022

    Montec Fawk Ski Jacket and Bib Review

    February 28, 2022
    8.5

    Canyon Lux Trail CF 7 Review

    November 28, 2022

    SRAM Rival/GX AXS Mullet Gravel Kit Review

    September 17, 2021
    9.1

    Bontrager Aeolus Pro 37 TLR Wheelset Review

    June 18, 2020
    9.4

    Roval CL 50 Disc Wheelset Review

    September 13, 2019
    9.1

    Bontrager Aeolus Pro 51 TLR Wheelset Review

    September 9, 2021

    Review: SRAM Force XPLR eTap AXS for Road?

    October 5, 2022
    Follow Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Advertisement
    Our Latest Posts
    • Black Diamond StormLine Stretch Rain Shell Review
    • Pearl Izumi PRO Barrier Jacket Review
    • Fresh Goods: Redshift Arclight PRO Clipless and Flat Pedals
    • Velocio Concept Merino Long Sleeve Jersey Review
    • Arc’teryx Rush SK 16 Backpack Review
    • Giro Montaro MIPS II Helmet Review
    • Outdoor Vitals Vario Jacket Review
    • Santini Gravel Bib Tights Review
    • Sportneer K1 Massage Gun Review
    • Review: Giro Latch Mountain Bike Shoes
    About Us
    About Us

    Since 1999, we have delivered in-depth gear reviews, articles and content. We feature a small staff of savvy, experienced writers who love to review outdoor gear.

    External links to Amazon, REI, Backcountry and other retailers include affiliate codes that give us a small commission on each sale.

    To contact us or learn more, go to our About Us page.

    © FeedTheHabit.com 1999 - 2023. All rights reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.