Facebook Twitter Instagram
    FeedTheHabit.com
    • Home
    • Gear Reviews
      • Mountain Biking
      • Road Biking
      • Bike Commuting
      • Trail Running
      • Skiing
      • Outdoors
      • Water Sports
      • Vehicles
    • News
    • Trip Reports
    • Videos
    FeedTheHabit.com
    Gear Reviews

    Columbia Extreme Fleece Baselayer with Omni-Heat

    Kevin GloverBy Kevin GloverFebruary 25, 2013No Comments5 Mins Read

    When people hear Nevada the last thing that comes to mind is cold and snow.  I grew up in Northern Nevada and I can tell you one thing – our winters are harsh.  The high desert is a place that tests adventurers and their gear; soft dry powder dozens of inches deep coat the Ruby Mountains and make them a paradise for backcountry skiers and deep-pocketed heli-skiers.  This is harsh, fragile country and it’s a perfect climate to test Columbia’s Omni-Heat Extreme Fleece base layers.

    Columbia Extreme Fleece Features:

    Tops:

    • Omni-Wick inserts keep you dry and comfortable
    • Omni-Heat thermal reflective lining for lightweight, breathable warmth
    • Performance fit
    • Antimicrobial
    • Ergonomic seaming
    • Thumb holes

    Bottoms:

    • Omni-Wick gusset and waistband keep you dry and comfortable
    • Omni-Heat thermal reflective lining for lightweight, breathable warmth
    • Compression tight, mid rise
    • Antimicrobial
    • Ergonomic seaming
    • Inseam length: 30”
    IMG_2905
    Omni-Heat receiving scrutiny from the resident Test Corgi, who appeared dazzled by the technology.

    My Experience

    I’ve tested Columbia’s Omni-Heat baselayer in a wide variety of conditions these last few months.  I took an overnighter to Lamoille Lake (9,740 feet) earlier in the season with about two feet of snow at the lake.  I’ve also spent several day skiing s at resorts with temperatures varying between the low teens and high twenties and the typical blasting Sierra Nevada wind, and a few trips of nordic skiing in single-digit temperatures.  My experiences with Omni-Heat convinced me of two things: it’s very warm but it doesn’t wick well.  Beyond that, the Extreme Fleece baselayer is a comfortable next-to-skin option that exhibits all of Columbia’s design expertise.

    DSC_0200

    The top features a half-length zipper for temperature control along with lightweight armpit panels that provide breathability and improve range of motion.  The top is tight-fitting but feels exceptionally comfortable – the fabric is stretchy and the the pit panels allow for totally unrestricted motion.  Thumb holes in the sleeves are a welcome touch but I frequently found them uncomfortable; the seams in the thumb holes form a sharp edge that digs into your skin.

    DSC_0204

    The bottoms are everything that I’d want in a baselayer – they have a textured waistband to help stay in place and Omni-Heat everywhere except for the groin.  My legs don’t sweat as much as my upper body and Omni-Heat excels when there’s not a whole lot of sweat to manage.  Columbia touts ‘ergonomic seaming’ in the Extreme Fleece baselayer, but I found that the seams caused mild irritation between my thighs when I was doing an activity like nordic skiing for more than two hours or so.

    Lastly, a little more about Omni-Heat:  I’ve used three Omni-Heat products (the Triteca softshell, Mountain Monster gloves, and the Extreme Fleece baselayer) and I’ve been able to get a pretty fair idea of what Omni-Heat really is – it’s a fabric that’s remarkably warm for its weight and provides the sort of heat that I thought could only come from trapped air insulation.  That being said, it doesn’t wick moisture as well as it should. When I used the Extreme Fleece baselayer for moderately aerobic activities that worked up a sweat, the fabric simply held the moisture and didn’t do enough to wick it away.  When I took off the baselayer it seemed that the silvery dots were coated with a sheen of sweat.

    I don’t want to overplay the wicking issue – it’s only an problem if you’re spending a night outdoors after wearing this baselayer and you’ll have to deal with all that moisture so that you don’t freeze to death.  For just about any activity in very cold weather, though, Omni-Heat is awesome.  You may find more sweat buildup than other baselayers, but it has to be said that the Extreme Fleece is a lot warmer than any other baselayer of its weight.  You may be a little sweaty, but you’ll be really warm.

    The Good:

    • Top is well articulated with great range of motion
    • Armpit and groin panels handle the worst sweat buildup
    • Omni-Heat is very warm
    • Waistband keeps bottoms firmly in place
    • Feel great next-to-skin
    • Legs are easily pulled up above ski boots without cutting of circulation

    The Bad:

    • Omni-Heat laminate could breathe better
    • Thumb holes grew uncomfortable over time – edge was too sharp
    • Seams in the pants caused mild irritation with friction
    • Tend to absorb body odors

    The Bottom Line

    Columbia’s Omni-Heat is a total winner and it’s an ideal technology for a baselayer — the silky-soft feel and surprising warmth/weight ratio make for a great next-to-skin option.  Moisture control is lacking, but I have total confidence that Columbia will continue to improve this fabric as more people grow to love the silver dots.  I would recommend this baselayer to anyone who lives and plays in very cold temperatures, but if sweat management is a priority over warmth this baselayer is not for you.

    Buy Now: Tops and Bottoms Available at Columbia.com

    39
    SHARES
    ShareTweet
    Columbia
    Previous ArticleBontrager Race XXX Lite Stem Review
    Next Article Bikes Built for Cobbles. Built for You.
    Kevin Glover
    • Website

    Kevin Glover lives, climbs and backpacks out of Spokane, WA. Originally from the Nevada high desert, he moved to the PNW ten years ago and has worked as a glacier and rock guide in the Washington Cascades. When not testing gear, he is a medical student at the University of Washington and will gladly check that rash out for you.

    You Might Also Like

    Schwalbe G-One Allround 650b Review

    June 7, 2023

    Patagonia Endless Run Shorts Review

    June 5, 2023

    Review: Outdoor Vitals Tern Ultralight Merino Hoodie

    May 31, 2023

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Most Popular

    Schwalbe G-One Allround 650b Review

    June 7, 2023
    8.9

    Zipp 303 S Carbon Wheelset Review

    November 4, 2021
    8.5

    Canyon Lux Trail CF 7 Review

    November 28, 2022
    9.2

    SRAM Rival XPLR eTap AXS Groupset Review

    August 12, 2022

    Moosejaw Ice Fort 25 Quart Hard Cooler Review

    May 17, 2023

    Wahoo ELEMNT Rival Multisport GPS Watch Review

    March 9, 2022

    SRAM Rival/GX AXS Mullet Gravel Kit Review

    September 17, 2021
    9.1

    Review: 2023 Trek Domane+ SLR 9 eBike

    December 5, 2022

    Review: SRAM Force XPLR eTap AXS for Road?

    October 5, 2022
    9.6

    Trek Domane SLR 9 AXS Gen 4 Review

    May 10, 2023
    Follow Us
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    Advertisement
    Our Latest Posts
    • Schwalbe G-One Allround 650b Review
    • Patagonia Endless Run Shorts Review
    • Review: Outdoor Vitals Tern Ultralight Merino Hoodie
    • Fresh Wheels: Pivot Mach 4 SL Gets Both Racier & Rowdier
    • Shimano S-Phyre Magnetic GR Sunglasses Review
    • Moosejaw Ice Fort 25 Quart Hard Cooler Review
    • Join Zwift “Ride Like King 15” Rides May 19-21
    • Review: Hoka Challenger 7 Road/Trail Shoe
    • Fresh New Bikes from Cervelo, Pinarello and Vitus
    • Trek Domane SLR 9 AXS Gen 4 Review
    About Us
    About Us

    Since 1999, we have delivered in-depth gear reviews, articles and content. We feature a small staff of savvy, experienced writers who love to review outdoor gear.

    External links to Amazon, REI, Backcountry and other retailers include affiliate codes that give us a small commission on each sale.

    To contact us or learn more, go to our About Us page.

    © FeedTheHabit.com 1999 - 2023. All rights reserved.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.